top of page

300. The Case of Phineas Gage: Unraveling the Enigma of Morality and Human Existence

The Enigma of Morality and Human Existence: A Glimpse into William Search's Theory

An Introduction to the Theory

In the captivating works "Why" and "Conversations with chatGPT: Exploring the Theory of Morality and Existence," author William Search delves into the complexities of human morality and the reasons for our existence. This blog post is inspired by the profound ideas presented in these books and aims to provide an in-depth exploration of the subject.

The Case of Phineas Gage: A Window into Moral Cognition

Phineas Gage's extraordinary story, as detailed in the books, sheds light on the relationship between the brain and moral behavior. After his tragic accident, Gage underwent a dramatic personality shift, sparking scientific curiosity about the brain's role in moral cognition. Theories of the time, like phrenology, tried to explain the changes by pinpointing specific areas of the brain responsible for various traits. However, modern neuroscience has advanced our understanding far beyond these early attempts.

Neuroscience and the Moral Brain

Modern neuroimaging techniques have allowed us to delve deeper into the brain's involvement in moral thinking. Various brain regions, such as the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, right temporoparietal junction, and medial frontal gyrus, have been identified as playing key roles in different aspects of moral cognition.

This has led to the understanding that moral thinking is not centralized in a single "moral organ." Instead, it is a multifaceted process involving diverse neural networks that also participate in non-moral mental processes (Damasio et al 1994; Greene and Haidt 2002; Miller 2008).

Emotion and Logic: The Pillars of Moral Reasoning

Neuroimaging studies have shed light on the age-old debate among philosophers about whether emotion or logic is primary in moral judgment. It appears that both emotion and logic play significant roles in the process, highlighting the complexity of human moral reasoning (Greene and Haidt 2002).

Open Behavioral Programs and the Emergence of Moral Behavior

Focusing on neural processes emphasizes the importance of open behavioral programs. These programs allow organisms to respond to changing environments and learn from their experiences. Moral behavior can be partly, or even largely, learned and shaped by local social environments.

The flexibility provided by open behavioral programs gives rise to the psychological level of organization. This level is emergent and relatively independent of lower-level functions (genetic and physiological). It also has the potential to influence these lower-level processes.

Conclusion: Exploring the Enigma of Morality and Existence Through the Moral Compass Theory

The works of William Search, as well as the scientific findings discussed herein, reveal the intricate nature of human morality and existence. By understanding the roles of neural processes, emotion, logic, and open behavioral programs, we can better appreciate the complexity of moral cognition and the human experience.

Tying these insights to the Moral Compass Theory, we can speculate that the purpose of our existence might be the growth and development of our moral compass. The complex interplay of neural processes, emotions, and learned behaviors allows humans to adapt and navigate the diverse moral landscapes they encounter throughout their lives. This continuous growth and evolution of our moral compass may be the driving force behind our existence, pushing us to expand our understanding of morality and, in turn, shaping the very essence of our humanity.

3 views0 comments


bottom of page